“Republican Glenn Youngkin began his term as governor of Virginia on [January 15] with executive actions that tackle education and the COVID-19 pandemic, including a ban on critical race theory in public schools and a lifting of school mask requirements.” CBS News
“Republican Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin [is] facing a new legal challenge over his executive action that aimed to let parents opt out of school mask mandates as his order took effect Monday but was ignored by some districts. Youngkin issued the order as one of his first acts after being sworn in as governor Jan. 15… On Monday, some students reporting to class ignored local mandates and went maskless. But there were no reports of major issues or violent confrontations. With the order facing a legal challenge filed last week [by] a group of parents and another filed Monday morning by seven school boards, Youngkin urged patience and asked parents to listen to their children’s school principals for the time being.” AP News
The right praises Youngkin’s actions so far.
“In his inaugural address, [Youngkin] reiterated many of the promises he made on the campaign trail. He affirmed the goodness of the American Founding. He said children should be in school, in person, five days per week. He said parents should have a say in education. He said he would cut taxes. He said he would make sure law enforcement is fully funded and supported. And then — this is the crazy part — he started actually doing those things…
“In a flurry of executive orders on his first day in office, Youngkin created a carveout from local mask mandates in K–12 schools for parents who don’t want their kids to mask, prohibited critical race theory in K–12 education, and ordered the attorney general to investigate sexual assaults in Loudoun County Public Schools. He fired every member of the Virginia Parole Board (which had been mired in scandal) and appointed new members ‘to restore integrity and confidence’ in the criminal-justice system. He withdrew Virginia from a regional green-energy initiative that was increasing electricity prices…
“The Left is busy convincing itself that Youngkin has morphed into a radical. Eileen Filler-Corn, the minority leader of the House of Delegates, called Youngkin ‘out of touch’ and said, ‘This is not the type of governor Glenn Youngkin promised to be on the campaign trail.’ But it is exactly the type of governor he promised to be.”
The Editors, National Review
Glenn Youngkin writes, “My predecessor issued executive orders at the beginning of the pandemic to accomplish what he viewed as his responsibility. Almost two years later, it is time to adjust our approach to the coronavirus emergency, while considering vaccinations, natural immunity, and the adverse mental and physical health effects on children. A path through the end of this pandemic is possible while also respecting individual freedom and choice. We can keep kids in school, provide a parental opt out to mask mandates, and protect lives and livelihoods…
“For the sake of our future generations, we need to recognize the potentially damaging impacts of mask-wearing on some children. Experts suggest masks can hide visual cues, hinder emotion recognition and reduce students’ abilities to hear teachers clearly. Studies also indicate that masks worn in public settings, school or day care might impact a range of early developmental and processing skills…
“There is no one better to determine what is best for children, especially after two years of a pandemic, than their parents. And only they should be able to decide whether wearing a mask in school is the right choice for their children.”
Glenn Youngkin, Washington Post
“Liberals have argued that critical race theory is not taught in classrooms, and for the most part that’s true… However, examples from Virginia’s Loudoun County and other school districts, where ‘anti-racism’ doctrines have been incorporated into teacher training and lesson plans, lay bare the dangers of poor-quality programs, implemented badly, that draw from the tenets of critical race theory…
“When a teacher expresses a partisan attitude or conveys partiality, something as little as an off-hand comment – ‘Your White privilege is showing,’ or ‘I would expect that answer from someone like you’ – can discourage students from forming independent thought…
“[Youngkin’s executive order] acknowledges that we must equip teachers with professional development resources so they can better prepare students to evaluate, analyze and think critically on difficult or controversial topics; to question and verify the credibility of sources; and to make informed judgments – all without imposing the teacher’s personal beliefs. All the while recognizing that most of what is taught in schools is noncontroversial… May his tenure help move us all toward sensible, principled conservative education policy.”
William J. Bennett, Fox News
The left is critical of Youngkin’s actions so far.
The left is critical of Youngkin’s actions so far.
"Youngkin showed why his message is so alluring in a Post op-ed this week in which he insisted on a point no one disagrees with: ‘Parents should have a say in education.’ The problem is how he translates that sentence into policy — which is precisely why he is facing a vigorous backlash against his executive order barring local school boards from requiring masks. Seven school boards have filed suit to overturn the governor’s ukase, arguing that it violates the state constitution, which vests control of education in school boards. Funny how conservatives love ‘local control’ until they want to impose their own preferences from on high.”
E.J. Dionne Jr., Washington Post
“[Last] Friday, a Virginia mom was charged in Page County with threatening to bring ‘every single gun loaded’ to her kids’ school on Monday. (She apologized, claiming that she was speaking of metaphorical firearms.)… [On Monday] There were dueling rallies between anti-mask parents and school boards demanding compliance. In Loudoun County, students refusing to wear masks were directed to school auditoriums where they did virtual work online. Some parents pulled their kids from school…
“Parents are frayed and starved for leadership. Some leaders have realized that the inflaming of tensions around masks garners votes. The problem is it also destabilizes government authority. Youngkin didn’t just turn student against student, parent against parent, or pit principals against educators and states against federal rules with the stroke of a pen the day he was sworn in. He personally modeled contempt for authority…
“The best way to ensure public contempt for every level of government is by pitting various parts of it against one another, dumping it all on the courts to resolve, and then telling a million parents to do whatever they want in the interim.”
Dahlia Lithwick, Slate
“Youngkin’s first week in office showed him to be a Trumpian culture-warrior. He immediately issued an executive order banning the teaching of critical race theory or any ‘inherently divisive concepts’ in Virginia schools…
“Because critical race theory is not actually being taught at K-12 public schools in the commonwealth, the order could only be an attempt to ban the accurate teaching of African American history, which necessarily covers slavery, Jim Crow repression, lynchings, ‘massive resistance’ to school desegregation, systematic discrimination and persistent disparities. If you teach Black history without bringing up any ‘divisive concepts,’ you’re not teaching it at all.”
Eugene Robinson, Washington Post
“[Youngkin has] also set up an email tip line that allows parents to report ‘inherently divisive practices’ in schools, including any attempts to enforce mask mandates and, of course, the teaching of what he terms CRT…
“The tip line in Virginia follows closely on other, conservative-led efforts to ban the alleged teaching of CRT and to remove certain books from school curriculums and libraries over various examples of wrongthink. The right is not new to book banning or to censorship writ large. The Christian right, for example, has long agitated against books with LGBT or feminist themes in libraries and classrooms…
"Despite the right’s uncompromising grip on censorship, it’s the left, often, that bears the public blame for cancel culture… [But] a few examples of liberal censorship, or language policing, do not make the left an illiberal force to match the right because Republicans in office are doing the bidding of conservative activists. Democratic governors have launched no snitch lines; there is no left-wing analog to the right’s war on so-called critical race theory in schools… Those who fear cancel culture are correct to do so, but they should be able to identify their real enemies.”
Sarah Jones, New York Magazine