Editor's note: We’re thrilled to learn that actor Chris Evans is working to create a bipartisan news site aimed at reducing partisanship and promoting civic engagement. If anyone knows how to get in touch with Captain America, we're all ears! In the meantime, we'd GREATLY appreciate it if you'd send him a quick tweet letting him know about us. A few dozen tweets could make all the difference. We've drafted something below, but please feel free to make it your own - every mention counts!
Hey @ChrisEvans Have you heard of @KnowTheFlipSide? You should check them out! https://www.theflipside.io/
Controversy erupted over the weekend about comments made by Rep Ilhan Omar (D-MN) in a speech to the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) in March. Omar stated, “CAIR was founded after 9/11, because they recognized that some people did something and that all of us were starting to lose access to our civil liberties.” YouTube
Rep. Dan Crenshaw (R-TX) tweeted, “First Member of Congress to ever describe terrorists who killed thousands of Americans on 9/11 as ‘some people who did something’. Unbelievable.” Twitter
President Donald Trump tweeted “WE WILL NEVER FORGET!” along with a video of her comments interspersed with footage of the 9/11 attacks. Twitter
The left argues that Omar’s comments were taken out of context, and condemns the over-the-top rhetoric being used against her.
“Omar was not downplaying 9/11, she was simply pointing out the injustice of all 1.8 billion Muslims worldwide being blamed for a small number of people committing a horrible atrocity… The only thing you could quibble with is Omar saying that CAIR — a blandly inoffensive Muslim rights organization akin to the NAACP, which conservatives nevertheless constantly accuse of being affiliated with terrorism or itself terrorist — was founded after 9/11, when in fact it was founded in 1994. (Though it did dramatically step up its advocacy after 9/11, for obvious reasons.)”
Ryan Cooper, The Week
“I’m reminded of Cardinal Richelieu’s quote: ‘If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him.’ Omar isn’t even being afforded six words… While some in the GOP are trying to use this moment to score cheap political points, Omar has been working hard to advance the 9/11 Victim’s Compensation Fund… [But] the most frustrating thing about this latest spasm of conservative backlash is the way it obscures Omar’s actual point about civil rights.”
Qasim Rashid, NBC News
“Since 2001, Muslim Americans have increasingly dealt with Islamophobia and threats of violence against them. The two most recent FBI reports on hate crimes showed that anti-Muslim assaults are at record levels in the United States, hovering at three times higher than they did a decade ago. Just this week, an Ohio chapter of CAIR asked the FBI to investigate after it received a threatening letter praising the New Zealand attacks as something that brought ‘tremendous joy’ and calling for ‘Death to Islam everywhere.’… The fearmongering tweets Trump and others pushed out in the wake of Omar’s speech serve as yet more pieces of fuel for this fire.”
Samantha Michaels, Mother Jones
“GOP Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel responded by calling Omar ‘anti-American.’ Fox & Friends host Brian Kilmeade said that ‘you have to wonder if she is an American first.’... [Last month Fox News Host Jeanine Pirro argued] that Omar isn’t a true American because she wears a hijab. ‘Omar wears a hijab, which according to the Quran, 33:59, tells women to cover so they won’t [be] molested,’ she said. ‘Is her adherence to this Islamic doctrine indicative of her adherence to sharia law, which is antithetical to the U.S. Constitution?’… It shouldn’t be hard to understand that pushing such a pointed message that people like Omar are at war with American values can lead to violence.”
Ryan Bort, Rolling Stone
“In February, authorities arrested the United States coast guard Lieutenant Christopher Hasson, an alleged rightwing extremist who, reports say, had placed Omar (among others) on a hit list… And just last week, a man from western New York was arrested for allegedly threatening to kill the Minnesota congresswoman. In scoring their cheap political points, Fox News and the New York Post and the president of the United States himself are directly contributing to a perilous climate of vigilantism that threatens not only Omar but really every Muslim in America today.”
Moustafa Bayoumi, The Guardian
Minority View: “The sweeping Mueller investigation ended with zero indictments of zero Americans for conspiring with Russia over the 2016 election. Both Donald Trump, Jr. and Jared Kushner – the key participants in the Trump Tower meeting – testified for hours and hours yet were never charged for perjury, lying or obstruction, even though Mueller proved how easily he would indict anyone who lied as part of the investigation…
“As Mueller himself concluded, a reasonable debate can be conducted on whether Trump tried to obstruct his investigation with corrupt intent. But even on the case of obstruction, the central point looms large over all of it: there was no underlying crime established for Trump to cover-up.”
Glenn Greenwald, The Intercept
The right condemns Omar’s comments and criticizes accusations of incitement against her critics.
The right condemns Omar’s comments and criticizes accusations of incitement against her critics.
“Is this the most important thing happening in the world? Not remotely. But it’s not asking too much from any elected representative to show that basic decency when they speak. Rep. Omar didn’t manage to do that. Maybe she misspoke. If so, it would be easy to say so, express a little respect for the dead and move on. But we’re not seeing that. Instead, Omar and her friends AOC and Rep. Tlaib and Vox and the Washington Post are claiming criticism of her language is an attempt to get her killed…
“Not one of the people on the left parroting this idea (that criticism incites violence) has shown any such concern about their own speech. When they spent the last 2 years claiming the president was a compromised Russian stooge, did you ever hear them hesitate on the grounds that someone might try to kill Trump? They did not. And neither should critics of Rep. Omar.”
John Sexton, Hot Air
“Last year, many in the liberal press applauded the public abuse of Trump officials in restaurants. This was the people having their voice! Even Democratic members of Congress urged this kind of direct action. Can they really claim that public confrontation with politicians is less likely to lead to violence than criticism of a Muslim politician’s speech? If telling people to get in GOP officials’ faces isn’t incitement to violence — and it isn’t — then how can criticism of a congresswoman euphemizing the attacks of 9/11 possibly be?…
“Omar has been the subject of death threats, including the arrest of one man. Perhaps Omar’s critics should take extra care in framing their attacks. But Omar is a public figure, a politician thrust into vast prominence and influence. She has to be fair game for direct criticism. And her identity cannot be allowed to transform a plain political attack into an incitement to violence.”
David Marcus, Federalist
Comparisons between Omar’s statements and those made by President Bush at Ground Zero imply “that President Bush said something comparable to her ‘some people did something’ riff, but the implied analogy is nonexistent. Bush vowed to destroy the terrorists who attacked the U.S. Omar suggested that the terrorist attacks were of little consequence except insofar as they prompted an alleged backlash against Muslims–by President Bush, presumably. The two statements could hardly be more different.”
John Hinderaker, Power Line Blog
Some, however, argue that “Omar's words were poorly chosen… But I suspect Omar's intent was not malicious or derisory. Rather, I believe Omar was attempting to draw divergence between her Islamic faith and the al Qaeda fanatics who carried out the 9/11 attacks. When she says that ‘some people’ did it, she meant ‘some people who are not us’ or ‘not like us,’ referring to herself and peaceful, mainstream adherents of Islam in the U.S… Maybe I'm wrong, but I think that was her key point: al Qaeda are not us, and their evil should not be used to collectively punish Muslims. You don't have to approve of CAIR or Omar to appreciate the legitimacy of this idea.”
Tom Rogan, Washington Examiner
“Colleges hike their tuition every year because they can. The feds have been willing to increase loan amounts to match whatever colleges charge. The result? Every dollar lent inflates tuition by another 60 cents, according to Federal Reserve research. In this heartless scheme, students are mules, carrying dollars from Washington to campuses nationwide. Never mind if they ever graduate or land jobs to pay back their loans…
“It would be fairer to require colleges to refund a portion of the loan money to Uncle Sam when a student doesn’t make it to graduation. Colleges need to have skin in the game, so they’ll try harder to get students through the course of study and into the working world.”
Betsy McCaughey, New York Post
“When the ideological left engages in what is variously denigrated as ‘political correctness,’ virtue-signaling, performative wokeness, or ‘social-justice warrior’ cry-bullying, many on the right find it easy to spot the flaws in those modes of discourse. But that discernment vanishes when the populist right indulges in the same vices…
“Civic conversation in America is dysfunctional in part because we have so many such outrage exhibitionists. These folks strip inartfully phrased remarks of context, ignoring the speaker’s intentions and imputing the least charitable possible meaning. This sets them up to display umbrage with the ostentation of a peacock… even if Omar’s words weren’t defensible, what kind of president uses the bully pulpit to push out video of a national trauma, forcing millions to relive its horrors, so that he can score cheap points against a member of Congress?”
Conor Friedersdorf, The Atlantic
This couple found a year-old lottery ticket worth $750K in a book – two days before the deadline.