June 10, 2025

NYC Mayoral Primary

New York City mayoral race front-runner Andrew Cuomo was forced to fend off a volley of attacks from his Democratic primary rivals in a debate Wednesday, with his opponents unleashing pent up barbs at the former governor in an attempt to crack his lead…

“Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist state lawmaker who has emerged as one of the leading candidates in the race, pressed Cuomo on the overlap between the former governor’s political donors and those who donated to Republican President Donald Trump…

“Incumbent Mayor Eric Adams, a Democrat who pulled out of the primary to instead run for a second term on an independent ballot line, did not participate in the debate. Cuomo had been considered one of the Democratic Party’s rising stars before his dramatic downfall in 2021 following a sexual harassment scandal. The former governor has said he did not intentionally mistreat the women and had fallen out of step with what was considered appropriate workplace conduct.” AP News

See past issues

From the Left

The left praises Mamdani.

“There are many reasons why Mamdani has taken off, including his unflagging focus on affordability in a city amid a crushing cost-of-living crisis. But one of the most important is the campaign’s army of thousands of volunteers… If part of the remedy for rising authoritarianism is more small-d democratic engagement, Mamdani is delivering it…

“As of late last week, the campaign had knocked on 644,755 doors and called 261,051 people… Mamdani’s platform — a rent freeze in the city’s nearly one million rent-stabilized units, fast and free public buses, building 200,000 new units of publicly owned social housing, municipal grocery stores to bring down the cost of groceries — addresses New Yorkers’ day-to-day struggles. Volunteers love talking about it, and voters love hearing about it.”

Liza Featherstone, Jacobin Magazine

Few New Yorkers seem genuinely excited about [Cuomo]. He lurches onward, the great juggernaut, attracting enough voters who see him as a corrective to the chaos of the Eric Adams years. Never mind that a sexual-harassment scandal drove Cuomo from office and that he faced repeated denunciations, from both parties, for how he managed the state during the pandemic.”

Ross Barkan, New York Magazine

“A recent poll conducted for the Forward found that among Jewish voters, Cuomo had 31 percent of Jewish voter support. Mamdani had a surprising 20 percent. New York City Comptroller Brad Lander, who is Jewish, was in third place with 18 percent. Since Lander is a left-liberal and a critic of Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu’s Gaza barbarism, many Jews who prefer Lander would likely back Mamdani over Cuomo…

“This confirms my hunch that liberal Jews, who are ashamed of what Netanyahu has done in Israel’s name, have had no place to go politically while the right has worked to conflate criticism of the Gaza war with antisemitism. Mamdani, who supports Israel’s right to exist but criticizes the Gaza war, could receive a nontrivial share of liberal Jewish support.”

Robert Kuttner, American Prospect

Some note, “Even if Mamdani becomes mayor, I will be concerned about how he got there and what it portends for the broader American left. It’s entirely logical that there are some fissures in the Democratic Party, which is made up of millions of people. What’s so troubling is how big and perhaps intractable those divides are…

“Will Democrats, instead of focusing on Trump, engage in a super-divisive, toxic presidential primary? If progressives and moderates remain divided by age, education, ideology and race, then the answer to that question seems, obviously, yes."

Perry Bacon Jr., Washington Post

From the Right

The right is critical of Mamdani.

The right is critical of Mamdani.

“On economics, Mamdani makes former left-wing mayor Bill de Blasio look like Milton Friedman. Mamdani’s agenda includes a $9 billion tax hike, freezing rent prices, free child care for all, free buses for all, and a $30-per-hour minimum wage. Mamdani opposes hiring more NYPD officers, wants to get rid of the Strategic Response Group that deals with keeping order at protests, and wants to eliminate the police overtime budget…

“We’re going to see a lot of this conflict in the 2026 midterms and the run-up to the 2028 Democratic presidential primary. A lot of Democrats deeply believe in the importance of using powerful elected offices as a way to divert taxpayer money to allied groups, to sign exorbitant book deals, and to allegedly grope armed state troopers, as Cuomo did. And a lot of other Democrats deeply believe in the government’s ability to solve all problems by throwing gobs and gobs more money at those problems, and raising taxes through the roof to pay for it all.”

Jim Geraghty, Fox News

Candidates sometimes don’t understand themselves how taxes work — and Mamdani is clearly one of them. Mamdani regularly compares the top state corporate tax rates of New York (7.25%) and New Jersey (11.5%). These are essentially the state tax rates on businesses profits related to their activity in a state. Mamdani says he’d ‘match’ New Jersey’s rate. On the one hand, that would be a windfall—for Albany, which collects the state corporate tax, not for New York City…

“Yet Mamdani doesn’t get that New York City’s biggest firms already pay far more than they would on the other side of the Hudson. Before anyone cuts a check to Albany, city businesses pay the Business Corporation Tax, at least 6.5% for small businesses and as much as 9%. On their remaining income, companies pay the state Corporation Franchise Tax, plus a surcharge to support the MTA. All-in, the top state-local rate for businesses in the city is generally just over 17.4%.”

Ken Girardin, New York Post

“They got to the Gaza war near the end of the two-hour [debate], with a discussion that led Mamdani to declare, ‘I believe Israel has a right to exist’ — but when the moderator prompted, ‘As a Jewish state?,’ he replied merely, ‘As a state with equal rights.’ As others quickly pointed out, that’s not Israel’s right to exist at all…

“‘There are 22 Arab Muslim states. In Mamdani’s world, there isn’t room for one Jewish state. He doesn’t want a Jewish state,’ notes Joseph Potasnik of the New York Board of Rabbis… Bad as everyone was on stage at the first Democratic mayoral debate, he disqualifies himself with that stance alone.”

Editorial Board, New York Post