“New York City will soon require proof of COVID-19 vaccinations for anyone who wants to dine indoors at a restaurant, see a performance or go to the gym, Mayor Bill de Blasio announced Tuesday, making it the first big city in the U.S. to impose such restrictions.” AP News
Many private companies are also requiring employees to be vaccinated. NBC News
Here’s our recent coverage of mask mandates. The Flip Side
The right is critical of vaccine mandates, arguing that they infringe upon personal autonomy.
“Why aren’t near-universal mandates ‘reasonable?’ Well, young people almost never become seriously ill from COVID — although a very few certainly do. But there is also some evidence of a very slight — but potentially serious — risk from the vaccines for the young. If we care about freedom, surely, for the young, vaccination may be the preferred — but should not be the mandatory — course…
“There is also significant evidence that people who recovered from COVID already have significant natural resistance to the disease. That being so, is it reasonable to force people with antibodies to involuntarily inject substances into their bodies, particularly since there is a very slight potential for serious bodily injury or death from the vaccine? No…
“Finally, the people most at risk of serious disease are the unvaccinated. People who choose to go unprotected are risking mostly themselves. Allowing them to face that risk is more reasonable than violating their personal autonomy.”
Wesley J. Smith, National Review
“The establishment’s response to [vaccine] resistance is to tighten the screws with mandates and vaccine passports, combined with condescending assurances about the vaccines’ safety. But if officials want people to take those assurances seriously, they should pass laws that will make people whole in the (very rare) cases they’re injured by the vaccines…
“As several people I know have said, the folks pushing the vaccines won’t be there for them if they have a bad experience, which can, as with any vaccine, lead to death or lifelong disability. Those folks will just tut-tut and assure us that such side effects are very rare. Well, the rareness of side effects is cold comfort for those few who suffer them. You know what could give comfort? Money…
“The ordinary vaccine-compensation program caps damages at $250,000 for death and disability. A COVID fund might award sums of $1 million for death or disability, plus lost income and medical expenses; a million is a round number that should reassure people. The vaccines are generally safe, so the expenses involved will be low, especially by comparison with today’s breakneck federal spending. Mandates and hectoring will only render the already-suspicious even more so. The far better route is a well-tailored incentive scheme that seeks to assuage the hesitant — without insulting their intelligence.”
Glenn H. Reynolds, New York Post
“A government mandate should be a last resort, not a first. Private companies are already setting their own standards for workers and customers, giving people a choice and an incentive to get vaccinated. There’s less justification for government coercion now than months ago with the pandemic having subsided and the city’s hospitals no longer facing the threat of being overwhelmed by Covid-19 cases.”
Editorial Board, Wall Street Journal
“More than 47% of white New Yorkers are vaccinated, according to Bloomberg’s tracker, compared to 33% of black New Yorkers and just under 45% of Hispanics in the city. That means that black New Yorkers will be barred from public accommodations at a far higher rate than will white New Yorkers. This is kind of an awkward policy. Nobody could honestly suggest that de Blasio is trying to discriminate against black people with his vaccine passport rule. But according to the racial politics that the Left and the media are trying to cram down the nation's collective throat, ‘Intentions in racism don’t matter. Impact does.’”
Timothy P. Carney, Washington Examiner
The left supports vaccine mandates, arguing that they are necessary for public health.
The left supports vaccine mandates, arguing that they are necessary for public health.
“The rapid spread of the delta variant means high vaccination rates are more important than ever — especially with the vast majority of severe illnesses and deaths occurring among the unvaccinated. Delta is so transmissible that experts think that 80% or more of the population may need to be vaccinated or have built up protection as a result of prior infection to reach herd immunity…
“Polling by the Kaiser Family Foundation suggests that consumer-facing vaccine requirements could work well. Nearly 40% of young adults surveyed said they'd be more likely to get a vaccine if one were required for attendance at large events. New York's requirement is much more expansive and could be more effective. And New York State’s digital Excelsior Pass, which provides proof of vaccination based on state records instead of a card from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, should cut down on fraud.”
Max Nisen, Bloomberg
“Vaccine passport programs have found success in other countries, and there’s evidence that these mandates boost vaccination rates. In France, for instance, a new health pass system that requires proof of vaccination for indoor dining, long-distance trains, and malls inspired protests — but also led to record sign-ups for vaccination appointments. Israel and Italy have also enacted similar vaccine passport systems to boost vaccination uptake and curb the impact of the delta variant.”
Rebecca Heilweil, Vox
“Any restrictions must be crafted strategically and compassionately… Everyone needs access to groceries, clothing and prescriptions. Many of the people who remain unvaccinated are already struggling, and prohibiting them from shopping for essentials would be an undue hardship…
“But what the unvaccinated can live without is seeing a movie in a theater, getting a spa treatment or observing happy hour inside the local bar. Imposing vaccine certification requirements on nonessential businesses would send a strong signal that having no shot equals having no fun.”
Editorial Board, Los Angeles Times
“A no-fly list for unvaccinated adults is an obvious step that the federal government should take. It will help limit the risk of transmission at destinations where unvaccinated people travel—and, by setting norms that restrict certain privileges to vaccinated people, will also help raise the stagnant vaccination rates…
“Flying is not a right… For the privilege of flying, Americans already give up a lot: We disclose our personal information, toss our water bottles, extinguish our cigarette butts, and lock our guns in checked luggage. For vaccinated people, having to show proof of vaccination when flying would be a minor inconvenience.”
Juliette Kayyem, The Atlantic
Regarding the pushback from some labor unions, “I know of no union that has opposed the requirement that school children and others be vaccinated against smallpox and polio, and this is a hell of a time for unions to start accommodating the anti-vaxxers…
“If union members have some obscure pre-existing condition that turns a COVID vaccine into a health risk, then exempting those members from a requirement is an eminently reasonable union demand in negotiations. To demand an exemption for anti-vaxxers and the merely fearful, however, is to condemn some of their own members to sickness and a heightened possibility of death—and to condemn people those members come into contact with to the same risks.”
Harold Meyerson, American Prospect
Researchers find real-life SpongeBob SquarePants and Patrick Star.
Good News Network